top of page
Search

Determinism vs. The Multiverse

Writer: Eddie Perkin
Eddie Perkin
Oct 15
2 min read

The Washington Commanders turned a likely win into a tie by letting the clock run out. It was the most prominent of several heavily debated decision processes from this past weekend's slate of NFL games.


Interestingly, we likely never would have witnessed the Commanders debacle if their opponent, the Giants, had made the analytically correct decision to go for two when down eight in the fourth quarter.


Sports, gambling, and investing share decision processes that operate under conditions of uncertainty. In making these tough choices, decision-makers fall into two categories: those who think deterministically and those who think probabilistically. I prefer the probabilistic approach.


A deterministic thinker sees outcomes as preordained. They use terms like fate and destiny. In the face of the unknown, they attempt to predict what will happen, assuming there is a singular path the future can take.


A probabilistic thinker thinks of a multiverse with a wide range of possibilities, including a few black swans in the tails that cannot be seen. The challenge is to estimate the probability of each potential future unfolding and then to act based on this range of outcomes.


In football, critics of the “go for two when down eight” recommendation seem to prefer the known uncertainty of overtime to the multi-path, higher-win-probability decision to attempt a two-point conversion.


At the blackjack table, the person who gets upset when another player "takes the dealer's bust card" is thinking deterministically. Ditto for the poker player who asks the dealer to reveal the next card so they know what would have happened.


Many investors approach the task of contemplating uncertainty by trying to put it in a box. They prefer the false precision of P/E multiples to DCFs. They generate pinpoint earnings and interest rate forecasts. At the start of 2026, Wall Street’s outlook for the 10-year Treasury ranged from 3.15% to 4.70%. It has since crossed 5.00%, above every single forecast in the consensus range.


The probabilistic investor doesn’t try to predict the future. We prepare for multiple versions of it by using ranges and scenarios, and frequently updating our assumptions as new evidence arrives. When the consensus coalesces around a singular deterministic, narrative, opportunities often present themselves.

 
 
 

Comments


  • LinkedIn

© 2026 by Eddie Perkin. All rights reserved.

bottom of page